Determinants of organizational performance of football clubs
https://doi.org/10.17747/2078-8886-2017-4-5-98-109
Abstract
Russian football currently finds itself in a challenging economic situation. In light of the upcoming FIFA World Cup in 2018 all members of the Russian football industry will be under immense pressure. Russian professional football clubs have been struggling to keep with European club management standards. This article aims to evaluate the industry-specific features of organizational performance within the context of professional football clubs. The current performance measurement system within Russian football is based on 5 straightforward licensing criteria, which do not conform with international requirements. During the course of the study the author was able to identify the main factors, which may be used to form a new performance measurement system for Russian professional football clubs.The findings of this paper allow to formulate the main directions of future research in the field of organizational performance of football clubs. The most acclaimed methodologies of foreign researchers attempted to combine both sporting and non-sporting (financial, marketing, etc.) indicators. The main theoretical findings may be used to modernize the current licensing system within Russian professional football. This article attempted to systemize the body of literature on organizational performance of sports organizations and football clubs by both Russian and foreign scholars. The conclusions of this study help broaden the understanding that in the current economic realities the ability to win competitions may not be regarded as the sole purpose of professional football clubs. Football clubs must strive to simultaneously achieve success on and off the pitch.
About the Author
N. A. Osokin
FGVOU VO (Federal State Budgetary Education Institution of Higher Education) “G.V.Plekhanov Russian Economic University”
Russian Federation
Lead Specialist of the Center for Strategic Research in Sports of FGVOU VO (Federal State Budgetary Education Institution of Higher Education) “G.V.Plekhanov Russian Economic University”. Scope of scientific research: sports management, sports economy, efficiency and effectiveness evaluation.
Russian Federation
Lead Specialist of the Center for Strategic Research in Sports of FGVOU VO (Federal State Budgetary Education Institution of Higher Education) “G.V.Plekhanov Russian Economic University”. Scope of scientific research: sports management, sports economy, efficiency and effectiveness evaluation.
References
1. Бич Д., Чедвик С. (2010) Маркетинг спорта. М.: Альпина Паблишер. 706 с.
2. Воробьев А. И., Солнцев И. В. (2014) Построение системы рейтингов в современном футболе // Вестник Российского экономического университета им. Г. В. Плеханова. №. 3. С. 110–120.
3. Воробьев А. И., Солнцев И. В., Осокин Н. А. (2016а) Анализ международного опыта развития футбола и его применение в России с учетом подготовки к чемпионату мира по футболу ФИФА-2018. М.: Инфра-М. 146 с.
4. Воробьев А. И., Солнцев И. В., Осокин Н. А. (2016б) Использование рэнкинговых моделей для оценки уровня развития футбола в странах ФИФА // Вестник Российского экономического университета им. Г. В. Плеханова. № 2 (86). С. 69–76.
5. Гуреева Е. А., Солнцев И. В. (2014) Оценка экономического эффекта от проведения крупных спортивных соревнований. М.: Русайнс. 130 с.
6. Солнцев И., Осокин Н. (2016) Спонсорство в футболе: оценка справедливой стоимости спонсорских соглашений // Экономическая политика. Т. 11, № 3. С. 69–81.
7. Солнцев И. В. (2016) Построение системы управления региональными спортивными федерациями на базе рейтингов (на примере футбола) // Региональная экономика: теория и практика. № 5 (428). С. 177–187.
8. Солнцев И. В., Осокин Н. А., Тарасюк В. В. (2015) Системы оплаты труда в спорте: опыт североамериканских спортивных лиг // Проблемы теории и практики управления. № 10. С. 56–65.
9. Andreff W. (2015) Governance of Professional Team Sports Clubs: Agency Problems and Soft Budget Constraints // Disequilibrium Sports Economics. London: Elgar. P. 175–228.
10. Andrikopoulos A., Kaimenakis N. (2009) Introducing FOrNeX: A composite index for the intangible resources of the football club // International Journal of Sport Management and Marketing. Vol. 5, № 3. P. 251–266.
11. Audas R., Dobson S., Goddard J. (1999) Organizational performance and managerial turnover // Managerial and Decision Economics.Vol. 20. P. 305–318.
12. Barros C. P., Douvis J. (2009) Comparative analysis of football efficiency among two small European countries: Portugal and Greece // International Journal of Sport Management and Marketing. Vol. 6, № 2. P. 183–199.
13. Barros C. P., Garcia-del-Barrio P. (2008) Efficiency measurement of the English football Premier League with a random frontier model // Economic modelling. Vol. 25, № 5. P. 994–1002.
14. Bayle E., Madella A. (2002) Development of a taxonomy of performance for national sport organizations //European Journal of Sport Science.Vol. 2, № 2. P. 1–21.
15. Bayle E., Robinson L. (2007) A framework for understanding the performance of national governing bodies of sport // European sport management quarterly. Vol. 7, № 3. P. 249–268.
16. Boscá J. E., LiernV., Martínez A.et al. (2009) Increasing offensive or defensive efficiency? An analysis of Italian and Spanish football // Omega.Vol. 37, № 1. P. 63–78.
17. Buraimo B. (2008) Stadium attendance and television audience demand in English league football // Managerial and Decision Economics. Vol. 29, № 6. P. 513–523.
18. Chadwick S. (2009) From outside lane to inside track: sport management research in the twenty-first century // Management Decision. Vol. 47, № 1. P. 191–203.
19. Chelladurai P. (1987) Multidimensionality and multiple perspectives of organizational effectiveness // Journal of Sport Management. Vol. 1, № 1. P. 37–47.
20. Dima T., Otoiu A. (2015) A Composite Index To Assess The Top European Football Clubs In 2014 // Revista Economică. Vol. 67, № 2. P. 68–85.
21. Ecer F., Boyukaslan A. (2014) Measuring performances of football clubs using financial ratios: the gray relational analysis approach //American Journal of Economics. – Vol. 4, № 1. P. 62–71.
22. Eliasson A. (2009) The European football market, globalization and mobility among players // Soccer & Society. Vol. 10, № 3–4. P. 386–397.
23. Football Money League: Planet Football (2017) // Deloitte. URL: https://www2.deloitte.com / global / en / pages / consumer-business / articles / deloitte-football-money-league.html.
24. Fort R. (2000) European and North American sports differences (?) //Scottish journal of political economy. Vol. 47, № 4. P. 431–455.
25. Frisby W. (1986) Measuring the organizational effectiveness of national sport governing bodies // Canadian Journal of Applied Sport Sciences.Vol. 11, № 2. P. 94–99.
26. Garcia-del-Barrio P., Szymanski S. (2009) Goal! Profit maximization versus win maximization in soccer // Review of Industrial Organization. Vol. 34, № 1. P. 45–68.
27. Gerrard B. (2005) A resource-utilization model of organizational efficiency in professional sports teams // Journal of Sport Management. Vol. 19, № 2. P. 143–169.
28. Giulianotti R. (2015) Sport: A critical sociology. Cambridge, UK: John Wiley& Sons. 264 p.
29. Guzmán I., Morrow S. (2007) Measuring efficiency and productivity in professional football teams: evidence from the English Premier League //Central European Journal of Operations Research. Vol. 15, № 4. P. 309–328.
30. ISO 9000 (2015). Системы менеджмента качества Основные положения и словарь (русская версия) // Kachest-vo.ru. URL: www.kachest-vo.ru / raz_4_standart / iso-9001–2015‑ru.pdf.
31. Jardin M. (2009) Efficiency of French football clubs and its dynamics // Munich Personal RePEc Archive. URL: mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de / 19828.
32. Kennedy P., Kennedy D. (2012) Football supporters and the commercialisation of football: Comparative responses across Europe // Soccer & Society. Vol. 13, № 3. P. 327–340.
33. Kiani Mavi R., Kiani Mavi N., Kiani L. (2012) Ranking football teams with AHP and TOPSIS methods // International Journal of Decision Sciences, Risk and Management. Vol. 4, № 1–2. P. 108–126.
34. Leach S., Szymanski S. (2015) Making money out of football // Scottish Journal of Political Economy.Vol. 62, № 1. P. 25–50.
35. Madella A., Bayle E., Tome J. (2005) The organisational performance of national swimming federations in Mediterranean countries: A comparative approach // European Journal of Sport Science. Vol. 5, № 4. P. 207–220.
36. Nardo M., Saisana M. (2005) Handbook on constructing composite indicators. Ispra: European Commission.158 p.
37. O’Boyle I. (2015) Developing a performance management framework for a national sport organisation //Sport Management Review. Vol. 18, № 2. P. 308–316.
38. O'Boyle I. (2012) The identification and management of fundamental performance dimensions within national level non-profit sport management: These / University of Ulster. Belfast.
39. Otley D. (1999). Performance management: a framework for management control systems research // Management accounting research. Vol. 10, № 4. P. 363–382.
40. Parganas P., Liasko R., Anagnostopoulos C. (2017) Scoring goals in multiple fields: Social media presence, on-field performance and commercial success in European professional football // Sport, Business and Management: An International Journal.Vol.7, № 2. P. 197–215.
41. Plumley D., Wilson R., Ramchandani G. Towards a model for measuring holistic performance of professional Football clubs // Soccer & Society. 2017. Vol.. 18, № 1. P. 16–29.
42. Richard P. J., Devinney T., Yip G. et al. (2009) Measuring organizational performance: Towards methodological best practice //Journal of management. Vol.35, № 3. P. 718–804.
43. Rohde M., Breuer C. (2016) The Financial Impact of (Foreign) Private Investors on Team Investments and Profits in Professional Football: Empirical Evidence from the Premier League // Applied Economics and Finance.Vol. 3, № 2. P. 243–255.
44. Rottenberg S. (1956) The baseball players’ labor market // Journal of political economy. Vol. 64, № 3. P. 242–258.
45. Satori A. (2011). A Blueprint for Successful Stadium Development // KPMG. URL: https://home.kpmg.com / yy / en / home / insights / 2013 / 10 / a-blueprint-for-sucessful-stadium-development.html.
46. Scelles N., Szymanski S., Dermit-Richard N. (2016) Insolvency in French soccer: the case of payment failure // Journal of Sports Economics. P. 1–22.
47. Soleimani-Damaneh J., Hamidi M., Sajadi H. (2011) Evaluating the performance of Iranian football teams utilizing linear programming // American Journal of Operations Research. Vol. 1, № 2. P. 65.
48. Szymanski S. (2017) Entry into exit: insolvency in English professional football // Scottish Journal of Political Economy. P. 1–26.
49. Szymański S., Kuypers T. (1999) Winners and losers. Harmondsworth: Viking Adult.
50. Terrien M., Scelles N., Morrow S. et al. (2017) The win / profit maximization debate: strategic adaptation as the answer? // Sport, Business and Management. Vol. 7, № 2. P. 121–140.
51. Transfer income and expenditures (2017) // Transfermarkt. URL: https://www.transfermarkt.com / transfers / einnahmenausgaben / statistik / plus / 0?ids=a&sa=&saison_id=2011&saison_id_bis=2011&land_id=141&nat=&pos=&altersklasse=&w_s=&leihe=&intern=0.
52. van den Berg E. W. A. (2011) The valuation of human capital in the football player transfer market.Rotterdam: ErasmusUniversity. 65 p.
53. Welcome to the 2016 edition of the PwC Sports Outlook (2016)//PWC. URL: http://www.pwc.com / us / en / industry / entertainment-media / publications / sports-outlook-north-america.html.
54. Winand M., Rihoux B., Qualizza D. et al. (2011) Combinations of key determinants of performance in sport governing bodies // Sport, Business and Management: An International Journal. Vol. 1, № 3. P. 234–251.
Review
For citations:
Osokin N.A. Determinants of organizational performance of football clubs. Strategic decisions and risk management. 2017;(4-5):98-109. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.17747/2078-8886-2017-4-5-98-109
Views:
2311
Email this article 